Really interesting discussion here. I started at FM5 and have gone both forward and backward since.
I did not experience the storefronts or older auction house while they were relevant, but what I find amazing is that the auction house UI was more responsive in FM4 than it is in either FM7 or FH4. I tend not to use them because of how slow the process is, both in displaying and in actually processing auctions. It is hard work with a controller, but they could for sure do something like an app that could interface with the game and auction house, and streamline all of that stuff. But then of course they canât even get their own loyalty app to work, so maybe not.
UI in general in 7 is poor, as has been said, seemingly a product of mimicking Windows 8 and the Xbox One home UI, which has been improved greatly since. A fully customisable one would be great, mimicking how the Xbox home UI is now. Having said that, the process of changing things like cosmetic pics and titles takes fewer button presses in 7 than in earlier games, except getting there in the menus⌠Also the blue/green/white box career grid of 3/4 was hideous compared to what we have had since.
The car collection game is silly for sure, and they still havenât achieved a decent UI for picking cars when there are so many. I feel like Horizon does it better, especially now with the ability to set everyone to party leaderâs car, but further back like in Horizon 2, still the best game of all of them, the â20 secondsâ to choose cars online was never enough.
Mods are more annoying to use than they are worth, definitely, but at least we got rid of brand loyalty, which was a mad grind especially in 4 and 5, and just made me want to never use those brands again, ironic when they gave bonuses for them. Also not helped by grindy achievements to max out loyalty.
As I gather, the drift mechanic was really good in 4, but then went a bit backwards? It was bad in 5 at least, especially for that nasty long beach drift achievement! They certainly donât give it the focus they could, anyway.
Forzathon was an inevitable addition, but is really fiddly, unimaginative and with pretty poor rewards. Even just the ability to click on one of the âchallengesâ and have it set up a race matching those conditions, would be a nice qol improvement.
Ever increasing grid numbers were a mistake, as was the underdog achievement. Against the AI you just have to be so aggressive in 7. Especially on some some tracks, like Road America, which they somehow seem to be much better at given the same difficulty settings. Also being able to change so many settings mid-race is impressive, but it is a shame that it is at the expense of the game -ever- encouraging you to improve your skills, given the static rewards, at least in XP, or is it credits? I forget. That is something that should be in the game, or even just moving up the car classes as it was in 3/4, oh and Horizon 1.
Not really bothered about music in motorsport, as compared to horizon, but I was actually impressed with the in-house effort they put in for FM7, especially compared to the minimal elevator music of 5.
7 certainly got the loading screen situation right, much quicker to load the first time, but for some reason, there is no quick restart race option, which is often just necessary with 24 grids. This is one that titles like Dirt 5 get perfect, with nigh instant loading for a restart. The Series consoles should of course help things out here again.
Going from 5 to 6 was exciting with the explosion in track numbers, but 7 was very lame in that regard, especially as they counted the FM6 expansion tracks in the new count, as well as the resurrected ones! Seemingly instead they added driver gear, possibly the lamest feature of all, given that you almost never see it. Definitely more of a horizon feature, and even there it sounds like they are toning it down in 5. For motorsport I feel they need to focus on more tracks down the line, to keep up the interest, but free so that they donât segregate the online play again! Adding more cars, and especially adding -back- cars from older titles, just pales by comparison, and homologation removes most of the differences between cars anyway.