Yeah, last year for christmas, I got Forza 5 Limited Edition and I was Learning how to use the Xbox One and when I didn’t know that I had to have a Gold Membership to purchase it, I decided to put on my brothers account at first but I didn’t get my vip membership or my 1250 car tokens so then had to pay another $20 for my vip membership. THATS NOT FAIR!!! I paid Microsoft $40 for my vip membership for Forza 5 when it was really only $20. That will not happen again. But I was just learning how to use the Xbox One. It was last year to.
On the Xbox One you need to purchase separate VIP membership for each account if you want the VIP advantages on each account. Purchasing it on one account does not make it work for all accounts on the console