In Replay mode the Engine Sound ist still broken!!!
In Replay mode manually rotating around the car with joystick is not possible!!!
Since the game was released the engine sound ist broken. It doesnt shift in sound. It sounds like you have only one gear. no shifting-sound. How is that possible NOT to fix such a major bug after all this years ? I cant understand that! (PC AND XBOX SX)
AND: Its not possible to rotate around tha car manually with the joystick in Replay Mode - WHY? If i do a “Reverse in Time” (Y) during the race, i can start a Mini-Replay. In that Mode it is possible to rotate around the car manually. In Main Replay Mode, after the race has finished, it is NOT possible to rotate around the car manually by joystick. WHY NOT?? Its a big mystery to me, how it is possible NOT to fix such a BIIIIG problem after such a long time ?
So PLEASE: Fix that broken Engine Sound bug in Replay Mode AASSAAPP !!! And make the manually rotation around the car in ReplayMode work.
Replay is identical to FM5/6/7. It was never possible rotate around yhe car or have a free roaming camera. So it’s not a bug
You should just ask for it in the suggestions forum (and it will be ignored so don’ t get your hopes up).
Also theirs no engine sound issues on consoles… Are you on PC?
In replays, your car data will be perfectly copied from race, but if u want to look at other players cars, u replays will make no sense, since oponent cars will use default stock car parts, so if someone engine swapped his car u will hear stock engine, that can go beyond this engine rpm limit, like if someone rotary swapped his Miata, u will hear no sound over 8k rpm but since it’s rotary it can go over 9k rpm, that also makes shift sounds bugged, and power figures are wrong.
I use Xbox SX AND PC. On both the Engine Sound of my own car ist broken, from release date up to now.
I did so many replays, and recorded them via HDMI recorder in Forza Horizon 4. No problems with my own cars engine sound. But in FH5 the sound of my own car ist broken. it sounds if my car isnt shifting and drives in first gear at maximum rpm. It sounds so terrible and makes any Replay Recording useless. Please fix this. The problem ist on PC and Xbox SX. Ill make a video.
FH5?
You are posting it the FM troubleshooting forums not FH5.
Here is the video with the major engine sound bug and no-rotating-around-the-car bug.
Video evidence for broken engine sound - no rotating bug
As you can see the car shifts normaly during the “race” till 9th gear. Also the engine sounds shifts correctly. all fine. Just bevore finish line i pressed (Y) to rewind a couple of times to start a mini replay. There you can see that rotating around the car manually with the contrller stick works fine.
The engines sound is already broken.
After fninishing the Race and start the Main Replay, you can hear the completely broken engine sound - not shifting “accousticly”. This major bug existst since the release of FH5 and it is broken on Xbox SX AND PC.
I am lost for words in the face of so much incompetence…or ist it just laziness???
So, first thing to do is to forward this bug report to the “devs” and fix this giant bug ASAP!!!
Second: fix that major bug not to be able to rotate around the car manualy by the stick in Main Replay Mode.
I cant belive that such essential problems have not been fixed in years. They create nonsense like Christmas Presents, Dynosaurs, and iglus while the Replay Mode is completely broken and unusable for years. What a shame and how embarrassing for the dev team. What a big big shame → mega facepalm
** PS: + Bring back the Mercedes SLR McLaren 772 GT finally to FH5…and the SLR Stirling Moss as well!!! …also as a car package for some $/€ if you like. The community has been waiting for it forever!!! So do it!!! You can!.. These icons of automotive history should not be missing in forza horizon 5… or in any other racing game. 