Boy, I haven’t seen that much of a long, heated discussion about the game for a long time. I don’t usually post things in forums, but I thought I may as well give my 2 cents worth.
I think both sides of the arguments have their points. I’m someone who is in the middle: I do the weekly Forzathon and races in about 2-3 hours each week, and then maybe come back to some of them with different cars if I found them interesting. I don’t do much rival and ranked races because my driving is decent but not excellent, and I don’t do the daily, so my weekly completion rate is about 94%. I do like to collect cars, and I’d say I got most of them except a few PO cars (BTW, I think the decision to remove them from AH is stupid… If people want to pay 20mils to buy a car that they’ll never use, I say let them… it’s their choice). I enjoy most of the Forzathon tasks, but I think the core of the problem is “How much is too much?” Why 15 thread the needle skills? Or win a Street Race 5 times? They can half the requirement to keep it challenging without being too much of a grind. Some tasks are hard by default (Like the tube jump), but they are mostly there since the game launched, so I just put up with it (BTW, I got lucky this week, and only took 2 tries to complete the jump)
The bigger issue for this game I feel is the dev got lazy to make it interesting. I remember about a year ago, they had a few championships using player/developer made tracks, and they were really fun. They could have done more of that. Also, I think it’s like 3 weeks in a row now we have championships using C-class offroad cars. They could’ve change it up a bit more, so we all get to use all the different cars in our garages. And on that point, I do have to agree that the game have shifted to focus on car collecting from actual racing. It’s great that they increased the garage limit from 750 to 1000, but why the tune limit is still 500? It doesn’t encourage players to try different cars as you simply can’t save your tunes. If they can find a way to increase the garage size, surely they can find a way to increase the tune limit.
BTW, I also play both Wreakfest and The Crew 2, and I have to say, for better or worse, FH4’s car collecting mechanic is decent. Now that The Crew 2 have removed the contracts task for you to earn Crew Credits, the new exclusive cars and vanity items are pretty much hidden behind a pay wall, and I gave up on the Summit for cars as I’d never make the top 3000 with my skill. In Wreakfest, yes, certain cars are better in each class than the others, but due to its game mechanic and AI, It focus a lot more on your driving skill (and A LOT of luck for the AI cars not crush you out of the race), so I’m happy not to own ALL the cars.
Like El Barto inc and IngoingCake8592 said, try to have fun with the game. You don’t have to do EVERYTHING. Do what you want to do, and leave the rest if you don’t enjoy it… It’s only game after all, your life is not depending on it