Forza Horizon needs to evolve!

Other racing franchises have reinvented themselves over the years and tried new things. Some games introduced police or went from supercars to street tuner cars, but Forza just stays Forza. It’s still a good and fun game, but so much can be improved or reworked.

I feel this game needs to evolve. Badly. Introduce something new, go a different direction. From FH1 to FH3 we’ve seen this game go from open-world to complete sandbox where you can drive anywhere you want. But between FH3 and FH5 not much has changed besides the graphics, colour toning and map.

Then there’s the details like sounds for example. You barely hear the turbo’s in this game, only a few cars have clear turbo sounds and they’re only decent.
Idle engine sounds are barely noticeable too. Why not let us hear a rumbling V8 when we’re standing still? Other racing games do this a lot better and continue to do so.

Then there is the much complained about Forza Aero and many other remnants from the early Forza Motorsport games that we still see in the current games (which makes them almost 20 years old!). The new aero on the Viper AE is a good step, but it’s still only available on one car.

The overall visual style is still the same too. I’m not saying we should go the NFS Unbound route and start adding anime style effects, but I would love to see the devs creating something new for a change. Add cops, try out a specific car culture, focus on a specific racing style or cars. For effects add more sparks, different exhaust flames, or add exhaust fumes. Neon underglow? Give us more customisation on par with competing games (NFS Heat/Unbound).

It’s still a fun game, but it remains pretty much the same as it has always been. I think it’s time this game started evolving, for better or worse. I get it all costs a lot of money and time, but if other studios are able to do it, why not Forza? Horizon would be the perfect game to experiment with, especially with the DLCs. Hot Wheels and Lego are the only real breaks we got but the downside of those is that they’re licensed themes, so likely not feasible to last long term (we all know the problems with licensing).

What do you guys think?

I’m afraid Forza Horizon has caught itself in a trap. It has too many features and game modes and it trembles under its own weight, yet leaving any of this elements behind (to shake and refresh the formula) seems unlikely, as PGG can be certain of backlash from one or the other part of the community. So the only possible way to evolve the series is forward, which means even more content, features, modes… as well as more bugs and other fundamental issues.

But who knows, if Forza Motorsport could get reboot, spending more than five years in the oven to be reborn with entirely new tech, perhaps Forza Horizon can too? On the other hand, Microsoft rather won’t green-light such idea as long as Forza Horizon remains their record-breaking first-party game…

Or maybe implementation of this new engine from Forza Motorsport in Forza Horizon 6 (?) will be enough to make another game in the series feel fresh enough? I guess we’ll see in 2024. For now we can just hope for introduction of some interesting gameplay innovation in the second expansion for FH5.

2 Likes

I hope they never add police chases. I can’t think of a single time they’ve ever showed up and been enjoyable in a racing game.

3 Likes

The FH5 Discussion section is for discussing the game as it is. For submitting ideas about changes to sounds, car customization, cops, effects, or new features, use the Suggestions Hub section where we can track those ideas.