FH Car Voting - Questions and Corrections (READ the first post)

These are questions that can be dealt with at a future time.

1 Like

Thank you

1 Like

Hey max, some Opel models are sold as Vauxhall in UK, it is possible to put Opel models as Vauxhall in the same page too?

2 Likes

Hey, @T10ManteoMax do you please can pin this quote above everything on Car Vote area as “READ THIS BEFORE VOTE” or something like that?

I feel people dont know that this is not a election and it is just a sugestion as name says and i think that not many peoiple are using the index as it is a bit not that updated and prefer use the search button, i think that the more people see this disclamer, the better for community will be, beacuse some people dont know this is not a election but instead is just a sugestions area, like the name says

1 Like

If I’m not mistaken, the Hyundai i30 is the same model as the Hyundai Elantra, diff name for different regions.

The Tuscan R was an earlier production iteration of what would become the production Typhon. These two pages should possibly be combined.

Are concept cars made prior to the 2010s ever going to get their own voting threads? I mainly ask because, while many of my car suggestions have had threads created for them, I’ve noticed most concept cars made before 2010 that I have suggested keep getting skipped over. It has happened too many times to be a coincidence. I feel like it’s also worth noting that a vast majority of the concept cars that I have suggested are not only fully-functional, but many actually still exist both in museums and manufacturer vaults, thus making it very plausible for the developers and/or outsourced teams to scan for their inclusion in the games.

2 Likes

It’s true I am skipping over older concepts at the moment but only to prioritize production and race car models or recent one-offs. It’ll take some time but I’ll get to the concepts eventually. As a whole, the three dozen or so concepts that have appeared in Forza history amount to about 2% of the 1600+ production/race/tuner models, and have usually been contemporary with the current game. But I wouldn’t rule anything out, especially with Forza’s relationship with the Petersen museum and manufacturer collections.

7 Likes

Fiat Fastback is the name of FIAT Pulse fastback model

1 Like

Potential Topics for Merging and then having a Poll inside as to which Version people would prefer to see

1 Like

Would be better as a joint thread for that and the Corolla Levin (seeing as they’re closely related), it’s either that or making it clear that Corolla Votes = Sprinter votes

Two things about this:
grafik

  1. Have the Topic Submissions and this thread in both categories
  2. It’d be better if they were renamed to “Road” and “Race”, rather than by game, seeing as both games have a mix of road and race cars
2 Likes

I actually really like that there is now a way to vote specifically for cars you want in Horizon or MotorSport so we can see what the top-voted cars are for each game. It was a great decision overall. However, looking at it now, I’ve noticed that basically every road car ever put in the suggested hub was now moved solely to Horizon. Is this an implication that MotorSport is done adding road cars? Is this an official declaration that the cars moved to the Horizon voting section will never be added to MotorSport? I doubt it! (and I REALLY hope it’s not). So if it’s not, perhaps the threads should have just been doubled & moved over to both games. I’m sure people would unvote for cars that they don’t care to see in MotorSport/Horizon if that’s not the game they care to see the car in…

1 Like

I’m working on a bulk add of the 3000+ models in the FH voting section to be duplicated in the FM Car Voting section, it just may be next week until we’re complete.

We’re doing this to get more specific results for the devs to quickly see which cars are most requested for each game.

8 Likes

Great to hear, I think it’s a super smart move! Sounds like a lot of work, so good luck! Will votes & thread notification alerts remain for both the FH & FM threads?

1 Like

We’ll keep the existing vote count in the FH section but users will have to upvote new topics in the FM section.

6 Likes

That is a great idea, it helps to know what community wants what and FINNALY eliminates that votes that askFM vs FH that sometimes were highligh unfairly agnaist motorsport

1 Like

Because the fictional cars like the Warthog and the Hot Wheels cars are based on existing products in a different IP that has existed for a long time. The Warthog has existed in the Halo franchise since 2001 and was designed internally by Bungie while Hot Wheels has been designing and making cars for decades now based on both real world and internal creations.

The issue with a car like yours is that A) there’s no precedent to base it on yet since it literally doesn’t exist at the moment and B) Who would own the copyright? Since you’re classifying it as a Nissan it would be theirs but they’re not making it and would probably just get their lawyers to send you a Cease and Desist if someone tried to add it to the game.

Your best bet tbh if you just want to design a concept car is to remove all references to Nissan and have it be a completely original design with your own brand.

There’s basically 0 chance at this point unfortunately that a AAA Developer would consider it as a Nissan due to all the legal implications and the fact they don’t have access to full reference materials to model it.

However I recommend checking out a game like Automation and also BeamNG though since you can actually build your car there and then drive it.

2 Likes

Regarding Cars like the Alfa Romeo Giulia that’s had it’s thread closed since it’s been added to FH5.

Would it not be possible to leave it open as there’s additional variants of the car that people are still very much interested in?

For the Giulia in particular the GTA and GTAm variants are incredibly popular and I see a lot of people in that thread requesting them.

Unless there’s going to be a new thread specifically for those variants but I don’t see the point in that

The older Giulia is also similar and even has an internal poll for the different body styles

Unless there’s internal information that there’s a 0% chance that the other variants of the car are going to be added but announcing that semi-publicly like this isn’t a good way to go about that imo

3 Likes

A question for the future: what will happen to closed threads when Forza Horizon 6 is released and it turns out that some of these cars are missing? Are topics going to be reopened?

Also, I support what @KillerSpectre21 said. Closing the thread for the modern Alfa Romeo Giulia when the Giulia GTA/GTAm is still missing seems a bit odd (and the same goes for other cars that have potentially desired variants not featured in the game) :wink:

3 Likes